Your Muni System is Under Attack

Muni Streetcar on Ocean Avenue, San FranciscoThe San Francisco Municipal Transportation Agency is facing a budget deficit of some $53 million over the next two fiscal years. Unfortunately for us, there are no obvious places for the agency to cut costs or generate new revenue – yes, they’ve tried everything, and the only option left is to cut transit service that is already at a historically thin level after a 10 percent cut just two years ago

Wait, what? The SFMTA has known this deficit was coming for years, and instead of exploring options to cut costs or generate new revenue, the stewards of our Municipal Railway have actually been toying with the idea of defunding the system even further by allowing kids to ride for free. Some of the options they’ve been ignoring include (list non-inclusive):

Now, under this board’s watch, we are potentially facing what new SFMTA chief Ed Reskin calls an “honest option” – making even deeper cuts to Muni service. Board chariman Tom Nolan went on to call this “right-sizing” of Muni service a “laudable and important goal.”

The company line, of course, is that all options are back on the table, but expect angry rhetoric from free-parking freeloaders at upcoming budget town hall meetings in opposition to anything that would constitute a minor inconvenience to motorists. The SFMTA will likely respond by indefinitely tabling these proposals and will instead address the deficit the easier way – by attacking Muni service. They know that any backlash from that action will be less than the backlash regarding, say, meter expansion, in part because of the challenges to organizing Muni’s diverse ridership. After all, riding transit isn’t a lifestyle for most folks in the way that driving is (readers of this blog excluded) – it is simply a way to get to work. Most of our fellow riders aren’t passionate about transit issues, they simply want their bus or streetcar to come on time and not be too crowded.

We need to communicate to our fellow riders, to the SFMTA board and to Reskin that cutting service is not an “honest option” for this transit-first socially conscious city – passing the pain off to those who depend on Muni will not be tolerated any more. We must stand up for the silent majority of city residents who rely on Muni everyday. We need to speak up at the town hall meetings, rant at board hearings, and even occupy One South Van Ness if necessary to get our point across that Muni service will not be the MTA’s ATM any longer.

This year brings the 100th anniversary of the Municipal Railway’s founding – San Franciscans of that era had the foresight to found a system that would belong to the public and be used for the good of the public. Now, our generation is tasked with defending “The People’s Railway” for posterity. Our task is not dissimilar to that of the “freeway revolters” who protected our neighborhoods and parks from a state highway-building assault – if this city is to continue being a city of the 99 percent, then we must prioritize mobility for all above the needs of transient motorists just passing through.

Weigh in on the SFMTA’s budget deficit and the possibility of service cuts by attending a town hall meeting, speaking at a regularly scheduled board meeting, or emailing [email protected].

4 thoughts on “Your Muni System is Under Attack

  1. njudah

    Well said. You beat me to the punch on this one – in all the talk last week the newspapers buried the lede of big transit cuts to a system that’s already been cut.

    It reallly is time for Tom Nolan to be removed from the SFMTA board. He has a record of tearing down the agency and sabotaging it with his suburban political view (i.e. transit is for “the poors” only so it doesn’t matter if it is cut). More importantly, blame also needs to be applied to the Board of Supervisors, who have rubber stamped the SFMTA budgets loaded with fare increases and service cuts. The death spiral has to stop.

  2. Joel Ramos

    Five Town Hall Meetings are scheduled:

    Saturday, March 3, 10 a.m. to noon
    SFMTA Headquarters
    One South Van Ness Avenue, 2nd Floor Atrium

    Thursday, March 8, 6 p.m. to 8 p.m.
    San Francisco City College
    50 Phelan Avenue, New Multi-use Building Room 140, 1st floor

    Wednesday, March 14, 5:30 p.m. to 7:30 p.m.
    San Francisco Public Library
    100 Larkin Street, Koret Auditorium

    Thursday, March 15, 6 p.m. to 8 p.m.
    SFMTA Presidio Division
    2640 Geary Boulevard, Training Rooms C, D and E

    Wednesday, March 21, 6 p.m. to 8 p.m.
    San Francisco Waldorf High School
    470 West Portal Avenue, Herbst Hall

    All meeting locations are accessible and served by Muni. For assistance in American Sign Language Interpretation or translation in other languages, please notify staff at 415.701.4790 or TTY 415.701.4730 at least 72 hours prior to the meeting.

    If you are unable to attend, you can comment on the budget via:

    E-mail: [email protected]
    Telephone: 311 or TTY 415.701.2323
    Facsimile: 415.701.4502
    U.S. Mail: SFMTA Board of Directors, One South Van Ness Avenue, 7th Floor, San Francisco, CA, 94103

  3. makfan

    Anyone who would talk about right-sizing Muni hasn’t stood on Sacramento St. some evening and watched 3 or 4 1-California buses pass by, unable to take on more passengers. Yeah, let’s cut the frequency.

  4. Pingback: An Open Letter to California Streets Readers | California Streets

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>